Dismissal of a Half-Million-Shekel Defamation Claim Against Yosef Haddad (CC 29776-07-24 Shlomi Eldar v. Yosef Haddad)

At our firm, we believe that freedom of expression is the lifeblood of democracy, and that legal proceedings must not be allowed to be used as a tool to silence legitimate criticism. This case, in which we represented Mr. Yosef Haddad in a defamation claim of roughly NIS 500,000 filed against him, demonstrates how sound legal management, a sharp strategy, and an in-depth understanding of the boundaries of public discourse can lead to the dismissal of SLAPP-style claims even before they reach the evidentiary stage.

The plaintiff, a journalist and documentary filmmaker, filed a massive claim against Mr. Yosef Haddad, a social activist and well-known public figure, arguing that various social-media publications constituted libel. The claim was filed against the background of sharp criticism raised by Mr. Haddad regarding the use made of clips from the plaintiff's documentary work, in which he raised questions about the plaintiff's connection to political organizations.

Our firm, representing Mr. Yosef Haddad, made clear from the very outset that this was a classic SLAPP suit, intended to deter Mr. Haddad from expressing his opinion and raising public criticism. We clarified that the publications at issue were protected under the broad defenses granted by the Prevention of Defamation Law, in particular the "truth of publication" defense and the "good faith" defense, which protect the expression of opinion and substantive criticism, especially where public figures and matters of public interest are involved.

Our firm's management of the proceeding focused on exposing the claim's lack of legal basis. We clarified to the court that the publications were made out of a sincere belief in their accuracy, as part of legitimate political and public discourse, and without any intent to harm. Our focused legal strategy, which included presenting a broad evidentiary foundation and emphasizing the importance of freedom of expression, led to the hoped-for result: dismissal of the claim even before we were required to undergo a lengthy and exhausting evidentiary hearing.

This achievement is not only a legal victory for Mr. Yosef Haddad, but a victory for everyone who believes in the right to express an opinion and to criticize the public sphere. Our success in this case underscores the importance of professional legal representation, capable of identifying SLAPP suits and acting decisively to repel them quickly and efficiently. Our firm is proud to continue protecting our clients and ensuring that their voice is heard without fear.

Back to Selected Cases